Megaphone
Blog

How to write about a failed business experiment on LinkedIn

Write a failed experiment post as a finished test report: the bet, the denominator, both results, the cost and the decision. Includes a Baremetrics example.

By Blake Emal · November 21, 2026 · 7 min read

To write about a failed business experiment on LinkedIn, report it as a finished test: the bet you made, the group you measured, the result you hoped for and the one you got, the cost nobody planned for, and the decision you made next. That structure shows customers, investors and candidates how you set a test, read the evidence and change course.

Decide the test is finished before writing about it

A failure post works best after the decision. While a test is still running, a founder can only describe a feeling about early numbers, and readers can't tell whether the result will hold. Once the company has stopped, changed or kept the experiment, the post can explain a choice.

Name the success condition you set at the start. A test failed because it missed that condition, or because it created a cost large enough to outweigh what it achieved. Writing the condition down keeps the post from redefining failure after the fact, in either direction.

Decide what you are willing to disclose before you draft. The guide to building in public as a B2B founder covers that earlier choice: which results, lessons and numbers belong in public and which stay private. This article assumes you have already decided to share the test and need to report it clearly.

Baremetrics published the denominator and the cost

Baremetrics, the subscription analytics company Josh Pigford founded, gives a clear example of a failed experiment written up in full. In his November 10, 2015 post on the Baremetrics blog, Pigford explained that the company had charged from signup, then launched a free plan in August 2015 with no time limit and a reduced feature set.

The post separated sign-ups from people who could buy. In that November 10, 2015 post, Pigford reported that more than 1,000 free accounts were created over 11 weeks, that only 461 belonged to companies eligible to become paying customers, and that 53 of those 461 upgraded. He calculated that as an 11.5% conversion rate in the same November 10, 2015 post and, at a $90 average revenue per user, nearly $5,000 in new monthly recurring revenue.

Then he reported the other side. Pigford wrote in the same November 10, 2015 post that free accounts soon outnumbered paying ones, the data Baremetrics stored and processed doubled, and the number of customers it supported tripled. Server problems meant paying customers saw downtime, delayed data and inaccurate metrics. In that November 10, 2015 post he reported that Baremetrics lost nearly 60 customers during the 11 weeks of the free plan, doubling revenue churn and producing a net loss of customers.

The decision closed the report. Pigford's November 10, 2015 post said Baremetrics had switched to a 14-day free trial that stops processing data for accounts that don't pick a plan, and it listed three setups the company could have tried instead, with the drawback Pigford saw in each.

One detail came out in the comments. Replying on Hacker News on November 10, 2015, Pigford said the lost customers were existing customers who left over technical and service issues, and that Baremetrics interviewed every outgoing customer. That answer tells readers how the company knew the cause of the churn. A failure report is stronger when it says where its explanation comes from.

The free plan also departed from Pigford's own stated rule. His MicroConf 2014 slides, posted on Speaker Deck on April 14, 2014, list "Charge from day one" among his takeaways from building Baremetrics. Naming the belief a test departed from helps readers see what was actually being tested.

For background, Rob Walling's YouTube channel has a video titled "How Josh Pigford turned an idea to $60K/year in 5 months," which, going by its title, covers Baremetrics' early growth. It is context on the company, separate from the evidence above.

Show which denominator produced the headline number

The 11.5% figure in Pigford's November 10, 2015 post is accurate for the group he defined: eligible accounts. Measured against all of the more than 1,000 free accounts in that November 10, 2015 post, the same 53 upgrades come to under 5.3%. Both numbers describe the same test. They answer different questions.

A failure post earns trust when it names the population behind every rate. Say who could have taken the action, over what period and how they were counted. If you exclude a group, say why. The founder content performance review applies the same discipline to monthly reporting: state what each count includes, which population it describes and what is missing.

Report the favorable result next to the unfavorable one. Pigford's post would have read as a growth story if it had stopped after the conversion rate. It became useful because it kept the churn in the same account.

Write the report in five parts

A failed-experiment report on LinkedIn needs five parts, in this order:

  1. The bet. What you changed, what you expected and the condition that would count as success.
  2. The group and the period. Who was eligible, how many there were and how long the test ran.
  3. Both results. The number that moved the way you hoped and the one that did not, each with its denominator.
  4. The cost and its evidence. What the test cost that you did not plan for, and how you know what caused it.
  5. The decision and its limit. What you stopped, what replaced it, and the situations where the lesson may not apply.

The following template is constructed for this article. Bracketed fields are placeholders for your own verified facts, not data.

We tested [change] for [period] because we expected [outcome]. Success meant [condition].

[Total] people signed up. [Eligible group] could actually [take the action], and [number] of them did.

It also cost us [cost]. We know the cause because [evidence source].

We ended the test on [date] and replaced it with [new approach]. This tells us about [our situation]. It says little about [conditions where it may not apply].

The template has no dramatic opener and no closing moral, because the decision in the last line already carries the lesson.

Once the test is written up, keep the record where the next post can use it. The Founder Authority OS gives you the playbook and worksheets to capture ideas like this one and review what your posts produced, so a finished experiment becomes source material instead of a note that gets lost.

Leave the lesson to the decision

Megaphone's own data suggests restraint at the end of the post. In Megaphone's study of 180,011 LinkedIn posts by 4,485 founders and CEOs, published November 3, 2026, setback stories that ended with a lesson came in at 1.62x engagement, against 2.29x for setback stories with no lesson. The same November 2026 study found that 73% of setback stories ended with a lesson anyway. That is an engagement comparison, and it does not show that the lesson caused the difference.

Several other habits weaken a failure post:

  • Opening on how the failure felt before saying what happened.
  • Recasting the failure as a secret success in the final line.
  • Blaming customers, a vendor or a team member who cannot respond.
  • Naming customers who left or quoting their private feedback.
  • Rounding a number until it no longer matches the system it came from.

Check what each reader will take from it

Customers read a failure post to learn whether it affected them. If paying customers felt the cost, as they did at Baremetrics, say what they experienced and what changed. Leaving it out invites the people affected to fill in the account themselves in the comments.

Investors read it as evidence of judgment. Megaphone's guide to LinkedIn and fundraising diligence argues that partners look at a founder's public writing before most first calls. A clear failure report shows how you set conditions, read evidence and stop a test. A vague one leaves them guessing about all three.

Candidates read it for how the company treats mistakes. A post that pins the failure on a team tells them more than the founder intended.

Assign the evidence check before it goes out

Every number in a failure post needs an owner who checks it against the system it came from before publishing. That includes the denominator, the period and any figure the founder remembers rather than looked up. If the founder writes from memory, someone else confirms the count.

Plan where the post sits in the week. A failure report needs every number matched to its source before it goes out, so give it a place in the founder content system with time for that review, rather than writing it the night a test ends.

When nobody inside the company has time to turn finished tests into posts, Megaphone Deploy adds an embedded strategist who finds the ideas inside your company's work, finished tests included, and drafts them for X, LinkedIn and email. You share the sources you're comfortable sharing, review one batch a week and correct a fact or a position. Nothing publishes without your yes.

Questions people ask

How do I write about a failed business experiment on LinkedIn?

Report it as a finished test. State what you changed and the success condition, who was eligible and for how long, the result you hoped for and the one you got, the cost you did not plan for, and the decision you made next.

What numbers should a failed experiment post include?

Include the denominator behind every rate, the period the test ran, and the result that went against you as well as the one that went your way. Check each figure against the system it came from before the post goes out.

Should a founder post about a failed experiment at all?

Post when the test is finished, the decision is made and the lesson helps customers, investors or candidates understand your judgment. Keep customer details, confidential terms and blame aimed at people who cannot respond out of the post.

Should a failure post end with a lesson?

Let the decision carry the lesson. In Megaphone's November 2026 study of founder LinkedIn posts, setback stories that ended with an explicit lesson drew less engagement than comparable setback stories without one. That comparison does not prove the lesson caused the difference.

Get the LinkedIn playbook, free.

Everything in these posts, in one long read, for someone with an hour a week.